After Further Review: Jets-Chiefs

By popular demand, we're again going to have a post after each game that breaks down some of the controversial decisions from the officiating crew in the game.

Penalty Count

Chiefs 9-57 (leading to zero Jets first downs)

Jets 6-32 (leading to two Chiefs first downs)

Note: This does not include penalties that are declined or off-set.

Plays where the call was obvious, uncontroversial or not visible on broadcast footage

Jets Penalties

  • Joe Tippmann holding. Had his hands on the outside, then lost leverage and pulled his man back and to the ground.
  • D'Angelo Ponds illegal contact. Grabbed his man around the waist, way downfield and with his back to the ball before a pass was thrown for a 3rd-and-11 incompletion. Very clear penalty.
  • Kenyon Sadiq facemask penalty to negate a first down. The officials did well to see it but he did very briefly have his finger caught in the facemask as he was stopping his man from getting lateral.
  • Andrew Beck kickoff out of bounds. A costly penalty from the Jets' interesting experiment. The Chiefs drove 60 yards to make it a two-score game.
  • Armand Membou unsportsmanlike conduct. Helmet slam after a third down sack.

Chiefs Penalties

  • R Mason Thomas neutral zone infraction. Lined up level with the ball. The ONLY Chiefs penalty on defense OR offense all day. Never mind that, though, did you know what the R stands for? You won't believe it!
  • Melvin Smith illegal touching. Downed a punt at the one but had been out of bounds so it counts as a touchback.

Plays that require further discussion

Jets Penalties

  • Sadiq false start. The Chiefs player moved first, but did not cross over into the neutral zone so it was correct to flag Sadiq for flinching here a half-beat later.
  • Mason Taylor false start. Flinched. Again, a Chiefs player reacted to the hard count but moved sideways instead of into the neutral zone. This time, Taylor was reacting to the movement of the defensive player.
  • Malik McClain offside on a missed field goal. A moot point because they missed the re-kick too, but slowing this down frame-by-frame, McClain timed it up perfectly and should not have been flagged.
  • Illegal shift on Taylor to negate the lone Adonai Mitchell catch of the day. Basically the exact same thing that happened last week. Taylor went in motion while Braelon Allen was shuffling into his stance and therefore would need to be set before the snap.

Chiefs Penalties

  • Holding on Jake Briningstool on a Chiefs kickoff return. Pretty clear wrap and takedown by Briningstool. Only notable because it was announced as on number 50 but the Chiefs have no player with that number on their active roster. The confusion was because they player held was the Jets' number 50, Troy Reeder.
  • Jadon Canady holding to negate a long punt return. Pretty obvious hold on Qwan'tez Stiggers as he tried to split a double vice. Perhaps most notable, though, is that there were three other possible holds on the return that were not called.

Notable no-calls etc

Here were some of the other notable missed calls, replay situations and controversial moments:

  • The Jets had to use a challenge to get the ball when Justin Fields' sneak was stuffed and he clearly lost the ball.
  • Tippmann got away with a hold on a Chris Jones pass rush.
  • There was one Chiefs fumble, recovered by Trey Smith, which was actually ruled down by contact. The Jets had nothing to gain by challenging this.
  • The ball hit the floor on Rashee Rice's low diving catch and his left hand came off it but it remained firmly in his right hand so he maintained control.
  • David Bailey had a tackle for loss where initially Kenneth Walker was not ruled down, but replay assist called down with the correction.
  • On the 25-yard screen pass touchdown to Walker, there was a possible hold on Jamien Sherwood. Mike Caliendo had a grasp of the outside of his shoulder pad. He just about let go in time to avoid being flagged but it could have gone either way.
  • On Bailey's second forced fumble, it arguably should have been Kingsley Enagbare who got credit. Enagbare hit the ball as it was in Patrick Mahomes' hand and it looked to be moving before it hit Bailey's helmet and came completely loose.
  • Mahomes was correctly ruled short of the goal line before Travis Kelce was correctly ruled to have broken the plane on the next snap.
  • Creed Humphrey got away with an obvious face mask on Jack Heflin on a first down run.
  • Mahomes had a sideways pass that hit the ground but this was correctly ruled incomplete because it was not a lateral. He threw it from the Jets' 32 and it landed on the 31.
  • Heflin should definitely have been called for running into the kicker but it was a good punt on 4th-and-11 so the Chiefs would probably decline the penalty anyway.
  • Azareye'h Thomas got caught up in a legal rub route on the play where Kelce beat him for 38 - his first play of longer than 20 yards allowed all year. This was about 3-4 yards downfield but Briningstool made it look like he was just running his usual route and happened to get in the way. Thomas avoided him anyway but it slowed him down. He couldn't risk running into him to try and draw a flag because obviously that would take himself out of the play completely.
  • On a screen pass to Breece Hall for a first down, Membou got away with a false start and Tippmann got away with a hold.
  • Some suggested Omar Cooper's injury was caused by a hip-drop tackle but who the hell even knows what one of those is?

Let us know what we missed - or misinterpreted - in the comments...