After Further Review: Jets-Raiders

By popular demand, we're again going to have a post after each game that breaks down some of the controversial decisions from the officiating crew in the game.

Penalty Count

Raiders 5-37 (leading to three Jets first downs)
Jets 6-32 (leading to two Raiders first downs)

Note: This does not include penalties that are declined or off-set.

Plays where the call was obvious, uncontroversial or not visible on broadcast footage

Jets Penalties

  • Austin McNamara kick-off out of bounds. Obviously tried to bounce it near the pylon and flew too close to the sun. This set up good field position for the Raiders, who drove for a touchdown.
  • Jarvis Brownlee defensive pass interference on Brock Bowers’ first touchdown. Clearly grabbed him as he broke to the outside, but still didn’t prevent the scoring pass.
  • Brandon Stephens’ defensive holding on Bowers in the end zone on third down. Obvious grab at the top of Bowers’ route.
  • Brownlee pass interference on 3rd-and-10 incompletion. Got crossed up and deliberately grabbed Tucker to prevent a probable big play. Probably a smart move to limit the damage from his obvious error.
  • Kingsley Enagbare offside. Lined up over the ball on Kirk Cousins’ successful quarterback sneak for a touchdown.
  • Olu Fashanu offensive holding to negate a 28-yard pass from Geno Smith to Garrett Wilson. An absolute killer but a fair call as he reached across his man to prevent him from getting to Smith on the inside.
  • Fashanu false start. Another killer, as Fashanu flinched before the snap at a time when the Raiders fans were making a lot of noise despite it being a Jets home game.

Raiders Penalties

  • DJ Glaze offensive holding to negate a 12-yard pass completion. Beaten inside by Enagbare, Glaze took him down to prevent the sack, so this was an obvious one.
  • Delay of game. The Raiders didn’t get the play off on time on 3rd-and-7 but scored anyway on the next snap.
  • Jermod McCoy defensive holding on Isaiah Williams’ touchdown catch. Obvious grab as Williams got past him at the goal line.
  • Hezekiah Masses defensive holding on Wilson. Very blatant hold here. In fact, he held him twice and maybe even three times.
  • Jeremy Chinn personal foul for a hit on a defenseless receiver. Another obvious call here, and an incredible job of hanging onto the ball by Wilson.

Plays that require further discussion

Jets Penalties

  • Demario Davis illegal contact on a play where Ashton Jeanty gained 15 on a short pass anyway. This was a weird one as Davis looked to shove Bowers as he passed him off into zone coverage but he seemed to get his angles wrong so he didn’t make contact until Bowers was 10 yards downfield and didn’t really slow him down as he was just shoving him in the same direction he was going anyway. As a result of dropping off deeper than planned to make this contact, Davis was out of position to prevent the dump-off from going for a big gain and obviously should just have aborted that aspect of his assignment.
  • Jelani Woods illegal shift. This only negated a short gain, but was still avoidable. It was arguably Williams’ fault as he realized just before Woods went in motion that the player inside him was on the line of scrimmage. Williams took a step back so he was off the line and then Woods started his motion but Williams was still shuffling into position so he was not set when Woods went in motion. That means Woods has to be set for a second prior to the snap, which he was not.

Raiders Penalties

  • Adam Butler defensive holding. As we noted last week, defensive holding on a defensive lineman during a running play is always difficult to parse. On this play, Butler was grappling with Joe Tippmann and he had two handfuls of Tippmann’s jersey that definitely prevented Tippmann from getting out to the next level, not that it impacted on the success of the run much. Butler clearly felt he was held initially by Tippmann too, although that was arguably just him trying to free himself from Butler’s clutches. Either way, Butler was demonstrably doing a thumbs-down gesture for several seconds which begs the question should that not be an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. Clearly an NBA player who did anything of this nature would be immediately T’d up, but apparently showing up NFL officials is fine as long as you don’t vocalize your displeasure.

Notable no-calls etc

Here were some of the other notable missed calls, replay situations and controversial moments:

  • Wilson’s fumble was correctly overruled. There was no way he even came close to making a football move before the ball was stripped out. He had barely landed having made the catch.
  • The Raiders wanted a penalty on Azareye’h Thomas as he made contact with Bowers near the goal line on an incompletion but this looked marginal at best.
  • The failed tush push by the Raiders very clearly never got to the line to gain and was correctly marked short on the field and upheld by the replay booth.
  • Cousins got away with potential intentional grounding on a couple of occasions.
  • The officials didn’t blow a Jeanty run dead when forward progress had clearly been stopped and then the Raiders got a late shove for an extra 4-5 yards. Such plays have always been blown dead sooner when they’ve potentially benefited the Jets this year.
  • Adonai Mitchell wanted pass interference on Eric Stokes on a downfield incompletion but this looked like little more than mutual hand-fighting.
  • The officials correctly picked up a flag after Brownlee had been penalized for holding again on third down. The fact a flag was even thrown here illustrates how officials are almost going out of their way to find penalties on the Jets in such situations because there was literally nothing anyone did that was close to a penalty.
  • It looked like Chinn’s toe might have been on the sideline when he made his game-clinching interception but the replay showed that he just about got it down.

Let us know what we missed - or misinterpreted - in the comments...