Three on O: Klubnik, Ruckert, Williams

After each game, we'll be highlighting three defensive and three offensive players and looking in detail at their performance. For a change, we'll start today with the offense:

Hope starts to Cade

Our first regular season look at Cade Klubnik, which may yet prove to be our last look at him for a while, saw him complete 11-of-20 passes for 137 yards.

Klubnik also scrambled for three first downs, which are the kinds of plays you want to see from a young, fresh backup, especially one with a limited skill-set and comfort level within the system.

He was just 7-for-14 for 100 yards prior to the final drive after the Bills extended their lead to 31-12, though.

Given what we saw of Klubnik playing against backups in preseason, expectations were never going to be high, especially seeing his first action in the middle of a game with limited preparation time (although they did at least get half time to prepare him, so he didn't have to enter completely cold).

The main takeaway from his performance, which included three completions for 20 yards or more, was that his accuracy is a major concern.

Even on the passes Klubnik completed down the field, he threw slightly behind the receiver, and the reason the hook-and-ladder was never going to work was because he threw to Garrett Wilson's inside rather than outside shoulder.

On a few of his misses, there were mitigating circumstances as he was under pressure on his interception, and off-balance as he tried to throw on the move on a bad overthrow to an open receiver on the sideline.

An important distinction to make is that there were plays where Klubnik was throwing right on time but the throw itself was inaccurate. What we more commonly saw with Zach Wilson and other recent Jets passers was that a throw that was criticized for being inaccurate but actually was right where it was supposed to be, but too late.

Klubnik had a throw to the end zone where he saw Wilson uncovering and threw to the back pylon but completely underthrew it and the defender was able to recover into position to not just break it up but almost intercept it. Had that been thrown up high to the back of the end zone it would be an easy score for a player like Wilson.

Similarly, on a play where Adonai Mitchell ran a deep out, something he's had good success with this year, Klubnik's release was right on time. However, it was behind Mitchell to his inside shoulder and again easy for the defensive player to recover and break it up.

The question then becomes is being accurate but consistently late easier to fix than being on time but having inconsistent ball placement?

And then, having said all that, the defining play of Klubnik's performance was maddening within that wider context. Wilson uncovers, is wide open at the goal line and Klubnik...decides not to throw it for some reason. He saw it, was looking right there, cocked back his arm and then didn't trust himself to make the throw and ran around like a headless chicken for 10 seconds before almost being intercepted on an under-duress 10-yard Hail Mary pass.

There's one more nit-pick before we turn this into a compliment sandwich and that's that when pressure came, Klubnik did a decent job of avoiding the first man. However, he then tended to drop his eyes and looked like a lost kid in a hall of mirrors trying to find a way out of a pocket that was closing in on him, but actually held up well enough for him to at least throw him away.

To his credit, though, on the few occasions where he was able to escape cleanly by stepping up, his head was up looking for opportunities downfield and, as already mentioned, he showed a willingness to take what the defense was giving him with his legs.

His best throw of the day was arguably this one. And, with the Jets having been penalized five yards two plays before it because they had 12 in the huddle, this otherwise could have been a touchdown which would have been a nice highlight for him.

We'll surely see Klubnik again this year, perhaps even on Sunday. If his accuracy issues will settle because he'll be more relaxed the next time he gets to play, he is seeing some things and may have enough ability to perform adequately with this good supporting cast around him.

Should we be excited that he's potentially the answer, though? Eh, let's see how he does next time out.

Water off a Ruck's back

Jeremy Ruckert is having a bizarre season. In Detroit, he caught a career five passes on five targets, including a clutch fourth down diving catch for a touchdown.

Since then? They haven't thrown to him once in seven games!

The latest twist and turn in this strange season came on Sunday as Jelani Woods, who has had more snaps than Ruckert a few times recently, was a healthy scratch. Does this mean the former third round pick Ruckert is close to being the same?

Anyway, we've established that Ruckert isn't doing anything in the passing game (unless we count a play where he whiffed on a block in pass protection but the resultant pressure didn't prevent Geno Smith from dumping it to Breece Hall for 16). But what is he contributing as a run blocker?

He was underwhelming this week in that area too, with his best block of the day arguably coming on a kickoff return. There are just too many plays like this where it's costing the Jets yardage because he's showing aggressiveness but his technique isn't good enough.

Ruckert did have one great play, though, as he did something most of the defensive players have been struggling to do and forced a turnover with this hustle play.

The Jets didn't draft Ruckert to force turnovers though, and his usage is confounding, as he has played 200 snaps but doesn't seem to be a consideration in the gameplan any more.

Cover your Isaiah

It's pretty obvious that the Jets had a gameplan in place that was going to heavily feature Omar Cooper on Sunday. Unfortunately, he was hurt on the first snap.

This forced Isaiah Williams into a bigger role as he played more snaps than he has in any game since week three. Prior to this, he had 12 catches, half of which were in the Packers game.

The production he gave them wasn't very impressive despite there being a lot of plays designed for the slot in the game script, as he was targeted seven times and this netted the Jets just 24 yards with zero first downs.

However, it would have been a decent statistical performance for Williams if his 45-yard catch and run wasn't negated by off-setting penalties.

This had little impact on the end result, as the Jets completed a long pass on the next snap anyway and ended the drive with a field goal. However, 5-for-69 would look a lot better for Williams than the 4-for-24 he ended up with.

Williams' increased role on offense meant he was taken off the kick return unit and probably played a role in the reason behind him waving for a fair catch on all three of the Bills' punts despite each of them appearing to be returnable.

29 NFL wide receivers have played at least 105 snaps in the slot, including Williams, who ranks 28th out of those players in terms of average yards per route.

Interestingly, both Cooper and Williams missed practice on Wednesday so the Jets could be without both of them. This could mean they go tight end-heavy on Sunday, but elevating Sterling Shepard again would be another option.

Right now, it's looking like Williams' 2025 Team MVP award is going to look like a serious anomaly down the road, and will probably make for a good trivia question in several years' time.

Three-on-D will follow tomorrow.